Thomas Boyce Jr. argued the case Weaver, et. al. v Mc Knight  134 C.A. 652 ( 2012 ) in Appellate Court.

In response to a Motion to Preclude the trial court precluded the opinion testimony of two of the plaintiff’s experts and then entered a Directed Verdict .

The plaintiff appealed to the Appellate Court.

The Appellate Court decision affirmed the decision of the trial court.